Skip to main content
DeepRoots Network
PoliticsMinnesota, USA / Iran / Israel / Japan

The Dilemma of Sharing Hidden Treasures in Indigenous Tourism

A travel writer contemplates the ethics of revealing quiet gems while navigating through the challenges faced by locals in popular destinations.

By Lyna BentaharSource: nytimes.com2 min read

In brief

On a solo journey through Japan, a travel writer grapples with the balance between promoting hidden gems and protecting local communities from the impacts of tourism, highlighting the complexities of sharing indigenous experiences.

As a travel writer, navigating the line between discovery and preservation can be a challenging endeavor. Recently, I undertook a solo expedition across Japan, savoring everything from the tranquil onsens of Mount Aso to the bustling streets of Tokyo. Amidst my wanderings, I stumbled into a quaint bar in Kyoto, the kind of intimate place where locals shared their world's secrets. This small bar encapsulated the spirit of Kyoto, where tradition meets modernity. However, as I conversed with the regular patrons, the question weighed heavily on my mind: Should I expose this hidden gem to the world, knowing that it may soon be overwhelmed by throngs of tourists? Pico Iyer, a seasoned traveler and writer who spent three decades in Kyoto, articulates this struggle poignantly. In a recent essay, he reflected on the uneasy balance between sharing the beauty of one’s home and safeguarding it from the impacts of mass tourism. The influx of visitors can shift the essence of a quiet destination, transforming once quaint cafes into busy commodities. Signs urging tourists to respect residential zones and crowded buses filled with foreign visitors illuminated the uneasy relationship between inhabitants and travelers, reminding me of the potential imbalance tourism can create. During my visit to Kiyomizu, the throngs of people made me feel less like an explorer and more like just another body in the crowd, erasing the intimate connection I sought with the place.This tension in travel writing emphasizes the importance of mindful exploration. While sharing the hidden beauties of indigenous cultures is a natural instinct for writers, it also comes with responsibility. As the popularity of destinations increases, so do the challenges of maintaining their integrity and charm. In our eagerness to uncover and celebrate the treasures of our world, we must also consider the impacts of our revelations on the very communities that make these experiences possible. Healing and honoring indigenous wisdom can be harmonized with a sense of stewardship, inviting travelers to engage meaningfully while respecting the spaces they explore.

Topics

More on this story