MEMPHIS, Tenn. (Deep Roots News) — A Tennessee judge has issued a ruling halting the use of the National Guard in Memphis as part of a federal crime-fighting order, providing the government with five days to appeal. This decision by Davidson County Chancellor Patricia Head Moskal reflects tensions between state and local officials regarding the deployment of military forces in response to crime.
Local authorities, including Shelby County Mayor Lee Harris, have expressed approval of the ruling, arguing that Republican Governor Bill Lee lacks the authority to deploy the Tennessee National Guard without explicit legislative action or a request from local governments in situations not involving rebellion or invasion.
The state contends that Tennessee law grants the governor the power to decide when the Guard should be dispatched, claiming it is essential for maintaining law and order as violence continues to rise in Memphis.
The National Guard has been patrolling various neighborhoods and commercial areas since October 10, despite the recent judicial ruling. The deployment forms part of a task force established in September by President Trump, aiming to combat rising crime rates, which have plagued Memphis for years.
In a statement, Harris regarded the court's decision as a vital affirmation of the rule of law, emphasizing that it impacts all Tennesseans, including the governor. The situation places ongoing scrutiny on the measures being taken within the Memphis Safe Task Force, which has already made thousands of arrests as crime remains a pressing issue.
While certain statistics indicate a decline in violent crimes, locals remain wary, demanding focused action on real threats rather than broad military deployment to manage public safety. This legal battle may further highlight the intricate relationship between public safety initiatives and the rights and roles of state governance.
