Pope Leo XIV's recent election has created a stir in American political circles, especially among supporters of former President Donald Trump. The first American Pope, hailing from Chicago, is seen diverging from the “America first” approach favored by many in the MAGA movement. Concerns over his political leanings have emerged, especially given his history of voicing criticism toward U.S. immigration policies and the Trump administration.
Despite the celebrations following his election, some influential voices within the MAGA community, such as former White House strategist Steve Bannon, expressed disappointment and concern. Bannon remarked on the “shocking” nature of having a Pope with an active social media presence that has criticized senior American officials. He anticipates friction between Leo and Trump, particularly on immigration issues.
Pope Leo XIV’s brother, John Prevost, confirmed expectations that the new Pope would not hold back on social issues, especially immigration, while many Catholics hope he will continue the more progressive agenda established by his predecessor, Pope Francis. Notably, a considerable portion of American Catholics supports topics such as legal abortion, diverging from traditional Church views.
In Chicago, reactions varied, with some local Catholics expressing hope that Leo would carry forward Francis's agenda. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops welcomed the new Pope, emphasizing that he belongs to all Catholics and advocates for peace and unity.
Despite the Pope’s relatively low political profile, MAGA commentators have been vocal about their skepticism. Some, like Ben Harnwell, allege that Pope Leo XIV aligns more closely with liberal ideologies—a far cry from the desires of the hard-right faction. Criticism extends beyond immigration to broader political issues as some prominent MAGA figures label Leo as "anti-Trump" and "pro-open borders."
The Pope's social media accounts, which date back to 2015, surfaced post-election, revealing past critiques of Trump’s policies and support for progressive positions that have captured attention and concern. The Vatican has yet to officially comment on the veracity of these accounts.
Vice President J.D. Vance has urged against the politicization of the Pope, stating that he will focus on prayer rather than public commentary. The broader implications of Pope Leo XIV's papacy on the American Catholic community remain uncertain, especially as key figures predict deepening divisions among Catholics—a sentiment echoed by Bannon who suggested that tensions could ensue, potentially impacting Trump's implementation of policies on immigration and social justice.
As observers await how Pope Leo XIV will navigate his papacy amid these political pressures, many remain skeptical of his both religious leadership and potential influence on American socio-political dynamics.
